Backpacker’s Pantry vs Mountain House – Who Has the Best Meals?

Although sharing a freshly cooked meal around a campfire is perhaps one of the most enjoyable experiences, it’s undoubtedly a bit of a luxury and one that most backpackers will not partake in. The main issue when it comes to meal prepping for a hiking or backpacking trip is figuring out how to get in all of your nutritional and caloric needs without weighing down your backpack. The less weight you carry, the less energy you use, and the more comfortable you will be.

For the most part, backpackers prefer carrying freeze-dried or dehydrated meals for their trips. These two types of meals are about as lightweight as you can get and are available in a huge variety of different flavors. Most only require water and a heat source to boil said water to make as well. They are more brands carrying backpacking meals than ever before. This is great news because it gives outdoor enthusiasts more options, but it also can be a bit intimidating trying to figure out which brand is best.

The only way of really determining which backpacking meal is the best is to give them a try. After all, one individual’s tastes may not be the same as our own. However, if you’re fairly new to backpacking and need a brand to start with, two of the most popular are Backpacker’s Pantry and Mountain House.

Backpacker’s Pantry Meals

Backpacker’s Pantry was founded in 1951 by Ann Benedict as a means of supplying the Girl Scouts with lightweight, healthy food for hikes and camping trips. It wasn’t until the company was purchased by the Smith family in 1971 that it began to focus on the consumer market. The folks at Backpacker’s Pantry are outdoor enthusiasts themselves, making them well-aware of the importance of tasty, healthy meals.

Backpacker’s Pantry meals focus on high in carbs, vitamins, and protein – all of which are important for outdoor enthusiasts. Not only are these meals known for being tasty and on the mark in terms of nutritional value, the Smith family also owns Colorado Spice. Colorado Spice offers natural and organic spices and herbs nationwide but is also why Backpacker’s Pantry meals tend to taste so delicious. Additionally, all Backpacker’s Pantry meals are MSG-free and are either organic or all-natural. Typical shelf life is 7 years, though their #10 can (designed for emergency survival) are rated for 25 years.

Compared to many freeze-dried meal brands, Backpacker’s Pantry has quite a detailed menu of options, if buying online. There are eight main categories on their website, including –

  • One Person Organic Meals
  • Two Person Meals
  • Gluten-Free Food
  • Snacks & Extras
  • Vegan Meals
  • Four Person Backpacking Meals
  • Emergency Foods
  • Lower Sodium Meals

Some of the most highly recommended flavors among backpackers include Granola with Bananas, Almonds & Milk, Fettuccini Alfredo with Chicken, Beef Stroganoff with Wild Mushrooms, Lasagna, Chicken Cashew Curry, and Mango Sticky Rice.

Backpacker’s Pantry has a much more elective selection of meal flavors, including Thai and Indian dishes. In that sense, they are more culturally-diverse and have a broader range of tastes. Strangely, the majority of breakfasts from Backpacker’s Pantry are sweet in nature. Average cook time is anywhere from 15 to 20 minutes, which is on the high end for freeze-dried or dehydrated meals. The typical pouch weighs just under 7 oz and all pouches are flat, meaning it can be tricky to fill the pouch or eat it. Backpacker’s Pantry meals tend to have lower sodium, but higher vitamin content and higher calories. Their meals retail for $4.50 to $10.90 per pouch.

Mountain House Meals

Strangely enough, Mountain House also has a bit of an unusual backstory. Mountain House originated as a meal production company for the United State Special Forces during the Vietnam war. During this time the military requested a new type of meal – one that was better tasting, lighter weight and had a longer lifespan than the K and C rations at that time. At this time the company was called Oregon Freeze Dry and they won the military contract.

To this day Mountain House still makes meals for the Special Forces and other military branches, but it was in 1969 that they began offering meals to the public. There were few brands offering easy-to-make freeze-dried meals during this time so Oregon Freeze Dry changed to what we know as Mountain House today. Throughout this time Mountain House has been one, if not the, most popular backpacking food brand. Adventurers of all times have relied on Mountain House on trips to both the North and South Poles, around the world on the highest mountain ranges, and were even used for the voyage to the moon.

Mountain House has a bit of a simpler approach to their meals. They break down their selections in seven categories –

  • Breakfasts
  • Entrees
  • Desserts
  • Sides & Meats
  • Emergency Preparedness
  • Camping
  • Military Rations

This layout makes it a breeze to find exactly what kind of meal you’re looking for.

In the Camping section, you’ll see Mountain House’s Top 3 Best Sellers for backpackers, which include Breakfast Skillet, Lasagna with Meat Sauce, and Biscuits and Gravy. Some of the most highly-rated flavors among backpackers include the Lasagna with Meat Sauce, Chili Mac with Beef, Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Breakfast Skillet, and Beef Stroganoff with Noodles.

Mountain House cook time averages between 8 and 10 minutes per meal. The typical meal pouch weighs less than 5 oz and all pouches have a flat-bottom design to allow them to stand up on their own. This design also makes it easy to eat directly from the pouch. Mountain House has slightly fewer calories per pouch, on average than Backpacker’s Pantry and slightly higher sodium. However, many find Mountain House meals to have a very savory, classic taste. You’ll find more traditional meals, such as scrambled eggs and chili mac. If you tend to favor classic American meal options that are very familiar to you, Mountain House is a great option. Typical retail varies between $5.99 and 8.99 per pouch.

Which Meals Should You Buy?

Both Backpacker’s Pantry and Mountain House are highly recommended brands. Each company has their own dedicated fan base, but there are also plenty of outdoor enthusiasts that have their favorite meals from both brands.

With all that being said, Mountain House typically checks out as having the better tasting meals and meals that reconstitute faster. Mountain House meals taste very much like good old home cooking to many, giving them a “comfort food” appeal while still getting all the nutrition you need. However, if you have dietary restrictions, chances are high that you’ll find more options with Backpacker’s Pantry. You’ll have gluten-free and low-sodium options as well as vegan meals, something rare among similar meal companies.

The only way of truly determining which brand is best for you is to give both Backpacker’s Pantry and Mountain House a try. Consider buying a few of the best-selling flavors mentioned and do a taste test. You can order from both brands online and many outdoor stores will have Mountain House in stock as well. In fact, you might even find some Mountain House products right in the camping aisle of your local Walmart.

About the Author Sam Hardy

Sam Hardy is an outdoor enthusiast with a penchant for survival prepping. He writes about the great outdoors and his favorite equipment here.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: